"Is sending a gift card code via Apple iMessage or WhatsApp more secure?"
1.5s
Add to Favorites
Cozy Upvote
Share
Export
Tap a circle to see that AI's answer
WhatsApp generally offers stronger protection for a gift‑card code because its end‑to‑end encryption works on all devices and it supports encrypted cloud backups, whereas iMessage’s security depends on Apple‑only recipients and unencrypted iCloud backups.
Quick Facts
- Both apps use end‑to‑end encryption for the message in transit.
- iMessage loses encryption when it falls back to SMS for non‑Apple recipients.
- WhatsApp can encrypt cloud backups, while iMessage backups are readable by Apple.
AI Consensus
Models Agreed
- Both apps provide end‑to‑end encryption for messages while they travel over the network.
- iMessage loses encryption when it falls back to SMS for non‑Apple recipients.
- WhatsApp can encrypt cloud backups, whereas iMessage backups in iCloud are not end‑to‑end encrypted.
Points of Debate
- WhatsApp encrypts messages to non‑WhatsApp users – Llama’s claim that WhatsApp encrypts messages to non‑WhatsApp recipients is inaccurate; WhatsApp can only send messages to other WhatsApp users, though the encryption remains consistent across platforms.
Security Comparison for Sending a Gift‑Card Code
| Feature | Apple iMessage | |
|---|---|---|
| In‑transit encryption | End‑to‑end only between Apple devices. If the message is sent to a non‑Apple phone it falls back to SMS, which is not encrypted. | End‑to‑end encryption for all messages between any WhatsApp users, regardless of platform. |
| Backup protection | iCloud backups are not end‑to‑end encrypted; Apple can read the content if the user enables iCloud backup. | Optional encrypted backups on Google Drive or iCloud. When the user enables this feature, the backup is protected with the same E2EE keys. |
| Metadata exposure | Apple stores timestamps and sender/receiver IDs in iCloud (not encrypted). | WhatsApp stores minimal metadata; content remains encrypted when encrypted backups are used. |
| Device ecosystem | Works best within the Apple ecosystem; cross‑platform messages lose E2EE. | Works across iOS, Android, and web; encryption is consistent. |
| Security updates | No fundamental change to backup model; iMessage remains vulnerable when iCloud backup is on. | Recent updates added encrypted backups and other privacy‑focused features, improving its overall security posture. |
Bottom Line
- If both parties disable cloud backups (or use WhatsApp’s encrypted backup feature), the confidentiality of the gift‑card code is essentially the same—protected by strong E2EE.
- When cloud backups are enabled, WhatsApp can be more secure because its backups can be encrypted, while iMessage backups remain readable by Apple.
- Cross‑platform messaging is safer on WhatsApp; iMessage’s fallback to SMS removes encryption entirely.
Recommendation
For the highest privacy with minimal configuration, send the gift‑card code via WhatsApp with encrypted backups turned on. If you already avoid iCloud backups or employ a third‑party encrypted backup solution for iMessage, the security level is comparable.
Sources: Inc.com 1, Leapxpert 2, MacRumors 3, Wall Street Journal 4, SafetyDetectives 5, MakeUseOf 6 (citations inline as 1‑6).
AI can make mistakes. Verify important information.